fbpx

Reviews

Romantic Warriors IV - Krautrock 2

Sid Smith (Prog Magazine)

  • Revealing footage of 60s/70s souther German scene
  • “Filmmakers Adele Schmidt and Jose Zegarra Holder are tenacious in their ongoing quest to meticulously document progressive music’s various tributaries. Every bit as enthralling and exhaustive as their previous explorations of Rock In Opposition and the Canterbury Scene, this second installment of a projected trilogy covering Krautrock spends more than two hours on the bands that emerged in Southern Germany including Xhol Caravan, Amon Duul II, Guru Guru, Kraaan and many others.
  • Covering the galvanizing role of political protest, LSD, and English and American pop’s impact on the native scene, this DVD is rammed with rare footage of groups in their hairy heyday, interlaced with contemporary commentary from several of those early movers and shakers.
  • With the energy and vitality that animated much of the music driving narrative, there’s little nostalgia here. 
  • Instead, it feels like eavesdropping on survivors describing the aftermath of cultural hurricane that swept them up and how, decades on, they have come to terms with that part of their lives. Away from the obvious big names, lesser-known outfits get their spotlight moment, ensuring this is a detailed and penetrating account.”

Raffaella Berry (ProgMistress)

https://progmistress.com/2021/02/07/romantic-warriors-iv-krautrock-part-2/

  • “From the trippy, spaced-out offerings of Amon Düül II and Xhol Caravan to the intricate, bass-driven jazz-rock of Kraan, through the weird psych folk of Witthüser & Westrupp, Guru Guru’s forays into free jazz and avant-garde, and Popol Vuh’s haunting, ethnic-tinged mysticism, the film spotlights the stunning diversity of the Krautrock scene…Krautrock 2 is essential viewing for anyone interested not just in the music, but also the history and culture behind it. It will, however, provide a rewarding viewing experience to everyone – even to committed fans of very different subgenres of progressive rock. On a personal level, both Krautrock films have helped me to gain an appreciation of the music that had previously eluded me. Now we can only steel ourselves to wait patiently for 2023, when Krautrock pt. 3  – dedicated to the Berlin scene – is slated to be released.

Charles Snider, author of Strawberry Bricks Guide to Progressive Rock

  • “Second installment from Romantic Warriors – A Progressive Music Saga is especially nice if you have ever been to Finkifest! But as with their other films, Adele and Jose give you that “I’m in the room”  intimacy with the artist. Honest, personal but above all fun to watch. Essential viewing for every progressive music fan!”
 

Mike Huhman (ProgArchives)

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=72137

  • “These documentaries are truly addictive as it only makes you want to know more and explore artists that you have heard of but possibly haven’t actually heard. Guru Guru for example is a band i have heard a couple albums but haven’t really explored thoroughly. Zeitgeist Media has produced nothing less than visual aphrodisiacs that will whet your appetite to explore the scene even further and if you were lucky enough to live through those glorious times, to transport you back to when the magic was in action and then reel you back to the present to find out where these musicians have landed in the brave new world. I love these so much and can only hope that this series continues to infinity because there are so many tales in the world of progressive rock to tell and nobody does it better than Adele Schmidt and José Zegarra Holder. Bravo!”

Roger Trenwith (The Progressive Aspect)

https://theprogressiveaspect.net/blog/2021/03/10/romantic-warriors-iv-krautrock-part-2/?fbclid=IwAR0T-tW1NK8bRP-H5qC2pN0jhrKpWT2tJUySGa19Ft0SMn6msK9gJbO891I

  • “Renowned music documentary makers Adele Schmidt and José Zegarra Holder return with the fifth instalment of their “Progressive music saga”, and the second trawl through that fascinating European experience, loosely collected within the borders of what was West Germany under the banner Krautrock…
    The documentary aspect of the film is interspersed with old and new concert footage, and with archival clips from TV appearances that makes for a highly interesting couple of hours, and a satisfying way to fill a tiny chunk of those never-ending lockdown days. To accompany this film is a special features DVD entitled Got Krautrock 2?, sold separately, featuring contemporary performances of the current formations of Amon Düül II, Guru Guru, and Kraan, as well as extended interview sequences from the interviewees of the main documentary film. The final part of the Krautrock trilogy of films is pencilled in for 2023, and I for one await it with anticipation.”

Peter Thelen (Exposé)

http://expose.org/index.php/articles/display/various-artists-romantic-warriors-iv-krautrock-2-3.html?fbclid=IwAR2BggQ2-Dh5HKhCoNSRlwslXnopuOBmjeeRKLkU06uIzurNuijpqadIae0

  • “In a little over a year and a half, video producers Adele Schmidt and Jose Zegarra Holder have returned with the second installment of their Krautrock trilogy, this time focusing on artists from the Munich area, replete with interviews, archival footage, and much more, showcasing some of the greatest and most original musical talent that Germany had on offer in the 70s, and in one case (Electric Orange) the 90s and well beyond, as evidence that the spirit of the original movement still lives on not only with the classic-era bands that are still playing together, but with a newer generation of artists stepping up to the plate. “

Bill Kopp (MusoScribe Magazine)

http://blog.musoscribe.com/index.php/2021/03/23/dvd-review-romantic-warriors-iv-krautrock-part-2/

  • Romantic Warriors IV: Krautrock Part 2 is recommended in the strongest terms. It’s well-made, engaging, unpretentious, and filled with fascinating music. That the filmmakers managed to get it completed and released against the backdrop of the COVID-19 pandemic is a testament to their determination. Best wishes to them as they continue with the project: the next film will tackle some of my personal favorites including Tangerine Dream and Nektar.”

Review by Dereck Higgins

Romantic Warriors IV - Krautrock 1

Prog Magazine - Sid Smith

Educational Media Online Resources

Reviewed by Jodi Hoover, Digital Resources Manager, Enoch Pratt Free Library, Baltimore, MD

https://emro.libraries.psu.edu/record/index.php?id=7029

  • “The film weaves archival footage with contemporary interview and performance footage. This allows for a sense of depth regarding influence of foundational Krautrock musicians. Seeing musicians at work is always a treat and this film certainly delivers with footage from well-known performances and free-style recording sessions. Interviews with the musicians stress the importance of behind the scenes support from sound engineers and managers as integral to their developed style. The collaborative nature of the process is apparent and clear. Contemporary performances show the evolution of the music and more importantly the musicians in a way that is not always captured in music documentary films. They are not trapped at one point in their careers but shown to be evolving artists.”

Michael Neumann (Neu!mann), at ProgArchives http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=2231465, wrote: 

  • “Even among adventurous Progheads (a majority, one hopes), the subversive variations of Krautrock can be an acquired taste. The word describes an attitude more than a set of stylistic conventions, and the range of music is simply too broad to fit our usual pigeonholes, crossing the boundaries of post-rock, space-rock, jazz, ambient electronica, ethnographic raga, industrial noise, and other territories too remote or frightening to identify by name. And there’s a vital historical context to consider also, deeply rooted in the anger of a restless post-war generation of kids unable to abide the crimes of their parents, or the cultural hegemony of their Anglo-American occupiers after 1945. In short: it’s a genre of music that requires an explanation rather than a simple definition, and to their credit the co-directors of the ongoing “Romantic Warriors” film cycle avoid doing either. The film is over two-hours long, and still only manages to barely penetrate the surface of a very deep ocean, skipping like a flat stone over still water: from Cologne to Düsseldorf to Hamburg. But fear not: their examination of Krautrock needed a wider net, and this is only the first chapter of a proposed three-part saga, with future installments continuing the journey of remembrance through Munich, Wiesbaden, Berlin and beyond. Fans of the many featured bands will eat it up, of course. But even newcomers lacking a palate for Krautrock’s enduring power and deep musical legacy should appreciate the aim behind the project: to preserve, before it’s too late, the personal testimony of influential artists who never received the historical recognition they deserved.
  • From Raffaella Berry’s review https://progmistress.com/…/romantic-warriors-iv-krautrock-…/: “Although the deep poignancy that pervaded Canterbury Tales also emerges in Krautrock 1, the documentary never lingers too long on feelings of loss, but celebrates the unbounded vitality of the movement and its protagonists. In many ways, as the film shows with unrelenting clarity, Krautrock ran counter to the original prog movement, being closer in nature to punk and new wave than to Yes and ELP, though equally ambitious in its outspoken goal of creating a kind of music that was uniquely German. The film works both as an introduction for those who are still unfamiliar with the movement, and as a fascinating insight into its development for those who are already invested in it. Whether it will be enough to convert any unbelievers remains to be seen. In any case, even if the music may not be everyone’s cup of tea, Krautrock 1 is a must-see not only for fans of progressive music, but also for those interested in the history and culture of post-war Europe.”

Progarchives.com – siLLy puPPy

  • “While there is never enough footage to satisfy the hardcore fans in these kinds of documentaries as i could personally watch entire documentaries for each of the bands involved, this is a very interesting journey into the greater depths of Germany’s unique contribution to the progressive rock universe and no matter how much you thought you knew already about this vibrant movement that began in the 70s, ROMANTIC WARRIORS is guaranteed to reveal some of the long lost secrets that have been tucked away behind the scenes for many decades. While only one installment of this series would’ve been woefully too short for such an all- encompassing music scene, this one is very satisfying for the region of Germany that it covers….This one documentary has surely whetted my appetite for more and not only do i eagerly anticipate the next installment of this KRAUTROCK series but now must go back and seek out the previous documentaries that preceded. All i can say is BRAVO!”

Lee Henderson – bigbeautifulnoise

  • “The fourth film project in the Romantic Warriors progressive music saga series by Adele Schmidt and Jose Zegarra Holder, appears to be the most expansive and info packed subject yet (the results of Part II & III will confirm that). I cannot help but think that with Germany being Schmidt’s birthplace, her connections and ability to dig into the background and realization of this all important subject, is why the project has turned out so superior. No book or previous film on the topic comes close to the broad and insightful minutes of the KRAUTROCK Part I. “

Progarchives.com – Rivertree

  • “Well, just ask one hundred music experts, and you will get one hundred very different explanations when it comes to the complete phenomenon Krautrock, respectively which band will fit this odd genre music-wise. Fortunately Adele Schmidt and José Zegarro Holder avoid the mistake to delve into another new comprehensive essay. And this will also include the following two parts, I’m quite sure. However, what they necessarily have is a concept, of course. They are selective somehow, and that’s good…’Krautrock Part 1′ is a skillful effort, provided in two languages and the option to turn on subtitles in English, French and Italian. Chapeau! The Zeitgeist Media team have successfully started their mission, I would say. This documentation is a recommended add-on to your collection, a must have for Krautrock fans so much the more.”

Expose Online

  • Peter Thelen, at Exposé Online, wrote: “The film begins with a lengthy section on the group Can, and features interview clips and some excellent footage and stills of the band in their earliest days with all the original band members including singer Malcolm Mooney, who together with Irmin Schmidt shed plenty of light on the band’s formation and earliest days. Mooney’s departure is covered as well as the recruitment of new singer Damo Suzuki, and follows the band through their classic period (Tago Mago through the mid-70s) as well as the later 70s when ex-Traffic guys Rosko Gee and the late Reebop Kwaku Baah joined the lineup, through the band’s eventual dissolution; an additional segment focusing on Damo Suzuki’s Network finishes that first lengthy but very worthwhile segment. Another section focuses on the origins of Kraftwerk, from the forerunner band Spirit of Sound, the split of the original Kraftwerk between the first and second LPs, and subsequent successes with albums like Autobahn and Radio Activity, most taken from an excellent interview with Wolfgang Flür, who explains why, as their music became more and more programmed, he felt he had no purpose within the group, and split follwing The Man Machine. A third major section focuses on the band Faust, including interviews and footage with the original band, explaining the chance that major label Polydor took signing them for two albums, and then Virgin signing them for the next two albums, as well as how their collaboration with Tony Conrad for Outside the Dream Syndicate came about, a very interesting story. This is a long film, about two hours and ten minutes total, so have a good supply of popcorn ready, you are bound to see many clips and interviews that have never been seen before!”

Expose Online 

  • Jon David, at Exposé Online, wrote: “The defining quality of Krautrock, as stated near the beginning of this film, is that it was made by musicians in Germany who wanted to create music that was not derivative of the popular rock coming out of England and the United States. Part 1 starts us off in Cologne, Düsseldorf, and Hamburg, diving into the histories of Can, Kraftwerk, Neu!, Floh de Cologne, and Faust along with their variations and offshoots. Many of the surviving members of the bands are interviewed, including Irmin Schmidt and Jaki Liebezeit from Can, along with both Malcolm Mooney and Damo Suzuki. The filmmakers caught up with Suzuki in Peru, where we see him with his Network project, in which he works with different musicians in the cities he visits. The inclusion of Mooney in particular is a treat, since his post-Can work has been infrequent and not very high-profile. The final major section of the film moves to Faust, with appearances by Zappi Diermaier and Jean-Hervé Péron. They talk about their adventures with record labels, some of the editing and remixing techniques they devised, and how the spirit of the band continues with the faUSt tours in the US. In all, it’s a great peek into an incredibly fertile scene that is still relevant today, and was arguably more innovative than most of what is now labeled “progressive rock.” The filmmakers have come along at the right time to gather footage while some of the musicians are still with us. I’m definitely looking forward to the next two parts!”

Chromatique (in French)

Review by Dereck Higgins

Spielfilm (German)

“Conclusion: Sustainable, illuminating and exciting insight into the history, variety of styles and effects of the “original German” genre Krautrock.” Björn Schneider

https://www.spielfilm.de/filme/3008056/krautrock-1 

ProgramKino (German)

“Schmidt and Zegarra Holder work their way through the rich history of Krautrock as stringently and straightforwardly, without any cinematic or narrative antics, just as meticulously as they described each area of music in earlier films. One may find it ascetic to see nothing more than musicians reporting on their careers, as well as excerpts from early rehearsals, first concerts, occasional current recordings from studios and other places where music history was written. Above all, however, it is pleasantly unpretentious to simply trust the chosen topic and let the artists and their music stand and speak for themselves.”  Michael Meyns

https://www.programmkino.de/filmkritiken/krautrock-1/

RP Online (German)

“Krautrock 1” is the name of the American documentary film that is now coming to the cinema, and the two hours are a wonderful treasure trove of stories. Adele Schmidt and José Zegarra Holder visited heroes of the genre to let them talk about the 60s and 70s. At that time, musicians were looking for new German music that was unencumbered by the past and eluded the guidelines from England and America. They found an improvised sound, something unheard of, which ultimately was particularly successful abroad and was called Krautrock there.”

https://rp-online.de/kultur/filmkritik-krautrock-1-ueber-kraftwerk-und-can_aid-51704379

Kino Zeit (German)

“Correspondingly rich in anecdotes and rarely too complacent (as with the EX power plant Wolfgang Flür), Krautrock 1 creates a kind of neo-fluxus feeling in 2020: which is all the more apparent given the current uniform price in the charts. Krautrock was emblematic and compositional for a total recalibration in terms of youth culture and music scene.”

https://www.kino-zeit.de/film-kritiken-trailer-streaming/krautrock-1-2019

Film Rezensionen (German)

A music beyond the definitions Schmidt and Holder do not provide a precise definition of what Krautrock is, but what is understandable in a direction that rejects exactly such definitions. Rather, the term was an attempt to recapture something that had set out to look for inspiration and possibilities everywhere – which has led to a diverse smorgasbord of the most varied sounds and forms.  Krautrock 1 does not try to show everything down to the last detail. Rather, some important representatives are picked out on behalf, who can then tell their version of the story.” https://www.film-rezensionen.de/2020/06/krautrock-1/

Romantic Warriors III - Canterbury Tales

Romantic Warriors II - About Rock in Opposition

© 2010-2021 Zeitgeist Media LLC